When a patient comes in with a cracked filling, the first question is almost always the same: what’s it going to take to fix it? The honest answer is that it depends, and not in a vague way. There are four or five realistic options, and each one suits a different kind of damage. At Lancaster Dental in Kitchener we’d rather you understand why we’re recommending one over another, so this post lays out the choices side by side, from the smallest repair to the biggest, and the things that tip the decision.
Three questions that decide the repair
Before choosing a treatment, we need answers to three things. Everything else follows from them.
- How much of the filling is affected? A chipped corner is a very different job from a filling that’s split down the middle or come loose.
- How much healthy tooth is left around it? A tooth with thick, strong walls can hold another filling. A tooth that’s mostly filling already may not.
- Is there decay or nerve involvement? Bacteria often get in through the crack. If decay has spread under the filling, or the nerve is irritated or infected, that has to be dealt with too.
We answer these with an exam, bite testing, a check for cold sensitivity and usually an X ray. Then we can talk options.
Your own priorities count as well. Some people want the longest lasting fix even if it takes two visits. Others need the simplest repair that will do the job for now. Both are reasonable, and we’ll be clear about the trade offs.
Option 1: smoothing or a small patch
Best for: a minor chip on a filling that is otherwise well sealed and in good shape.
Sometimes a tiny piece breaks off the edge of a filling and leaves a rough spot, but the rest of the filling is solid. In that case we may just polish the area smooth, or add a small amount of tooth coloured material to fill in the chip. It’s quick, often needs no freezing and keeps as much of the original work as possible.
The catch is that patches only work when the underlying filling is sound. If there’s any sign of leakage or decay at the edges, patching just covers up a problem.
Option 2: a replacement filling
Best for: a cracked, loose or leaking filling in a tooth that still has plenty of strong structure.
This is the most common fix. We numb the tooth, remove the old filling, clean out any decay underneath and place a new one. Removing the old material is useful in itself, because it lets us see exactly what’s going on inside the tooth, including small cracks that weren’t visible before.
Choosing the material
Many old fillings are silver coloured amalgam. When they’re replaced, most people now choose composite, a tooth coloured resin that bonds to the tooth. A few points worth knowing:
- Composite blends in, which matters for teeth that show when you smile
- Because it bonds to the tooth, it can sometimes be placed with less drilling
- On very large fillings in back teeth that take heavy chewing forces, other options may hold up better
We’ll tell you what we’d recommend for that particular tooth and why.
Option 3: a crown
Best for: a tooth that’s mostly filling, has cracks running into the tooth itself, or has had root canal treatment.
A crown covers the whole visible part of the tooth, like a cap. It holds the tooth together and spreads chewing forces across it, which helps stop a cracked tooth from splitting further. When a filling has failed more than once, or most of the tooth’s walls are thin, a crown is often the restoration most likely to last.
Getting a crown usually takes two visits. At the first, the tooth is shaped and an impression or scan is taken, and you leave with a temporary. At the second, the permanent crown is checked for fit and colour and then cemented.
Option 4: root canal treatment, then a restoration
Best for: a tooth where bacteria have reached the nerve, causing lingering pain, throbbing or infection.
If a crack has let bacteria reach the pulp, replacing the filling alone won’t solve the problem. Root canal treatment removes the infected or inflamed tissue from inside the tooth, cleans and seals the canals, and stops the pain. Afterward, the tooth almost always needs a crown, because it’s become more brittle.
Comparing the options at a glance
- Smoothing or patch: fastest and simplest, only for small chips on sound fillings
- Replacement filling: one visit, suits most cracked fillings when the tooth is still strong
- Crown: two visits, the most protection for weak or cracked teeth
- Root canal plus crown: needed when the nerve is affected
What happens if you wait
A cracked filling can look like a small problem for a long time, which is exactly why people put it off. Meanwhile, the gap lets bacteria in. Decay under a filling is hard to spot until it’s large, and a crack in the tooth can grow a little with every bite. Each step down that road moves you further along the list above: from a patch to a new filling, from a filling to a crown, from a crown to a root canal. Coming in early is the simplest way to keep the repair small.
Common questions about cracked filling repair
Can you just fix part of the filling?
Sometimes, if the rest of it is in good shape. If there’s any doubt about the seal, replacing it is usually the safer choice.
Why do some teeth need a crown instead of another filling?
Each time a filling is replaced, a bit more tooth is lost. Eventually the walls get too thin to hold a filling safely. A crown protects what’s left.
How long will the repair last?
It depends on the size of the repair, the material, your bite and habits like grinding. Regular checkups help us catch wear early. If you grind your teeth, a night guard can add years to any restoration.
Book a cracked filling assessment in Kitchener
If a filling feels rough, sharp or sensitive, or you’ve felt a piece break off, come in and let us take a look. We’ll explain what we see and which repair makes sense, so you can decide with all the facts. Call Lancaster Dental at 519-578-9670. We’re at 493 Lancaster Street West, Suite 206, in Kitchener.
If a filling feels rough or cracked, call us at 519-578-9670 or read about composite fillings in Kitchener.